Is Muslims' Demand of only Civil Code of Sharia in Non-Muslim Majority Countries Justified?
Susmit Kumar, Ph.D.
(This is reply to an Indian Muslim who wrote to Dr Kumar that India should continue to have religion-based civil code).
Yes, you have a valid point about common code, i.e. there should be religious freedom. But why do you stop at choosing only civil code and not criminal aspect of Muslim code? If the court convicts a person, he will go to prison if he is a non-Muslim (Hindu, Christian, Parsi or Sikh), but if he is a Muslim, his limbs (hand/leg) will be cut off, eye put out or death by stoning according your Sharia law. Why do not you ask for this in India, i.e. criminal aspect of Muslim code? You can not choose what you like in your religion and discard what you do not like.